Peacock has quietly carved out a significant place in the U.S. streaming landscape, even without the prestige of HBO Max or the sheer volume of Netflix. Its main strength, as highlighted in Tom's Guide annual report card, is an impressive array of live programming. Over the past year, the platform has aired the Winter Olympics, the Super Bowl and, thanks to Telemundo, Spanish-language broadcasts of the 2026 World Cup. In addition, it offers NFL, NBA, WNBA and MLB games, as well as the Premier League.
The overall grade assigned to Peacock is a B, a solid result reflecting high average quality but with some critical issues. The highest score comes for live content, which merits an A+ without debate. However, the platform shows limitations in its interface and original productions, which fail to compete with industry giants. Furthermore, an upcoming price increase could negatively impact future ratings.
A price that rises after a year of advantageous offers
Until now, Peacock has been considered one of the most affordable streaming services, offering good value for money. But that is about to change, with a hike affecting all subscription tiers. Currently, there are three available plans. The first, called Peacock Select, costs $7.99 per month and includes only the library of TV shows, excluding sports, movies and original content. It is designed for those who want access to NBCUniversal's catalog at a lower price.
Sponsored Protocol
The mid-tier plan, Peacock Premium, is priced at $10.99 per month and unlocks the full offering, including live sports, films and original content, but with ads. Finally, Peacock Premium Plus, at $16.99, removes most ads, adds offline downloads and includes your local NBC station live. Despite the higher cost, the variety of live events makes this subscription particularly appealing for sports fans. Tom's Guide gives a B for pricing, noting that the future increase could lower the grade in the next review.
Library leverages NBCUniversal's heritage effectively
Peacock's strength also lies in its library, drawing on decades of NBCUniversal television programming. Shows like The Office, the Law & Order universe, Parks and Recreation, 30 Rock, Brooklyn Nine-Nine and Saturday Night Live are a constant draw. But the real ace in the hole is the Bravo catalog, with reality shows like Real Housewives, Below Deck, Vanderpump Rules and Top Chef, which alone would justify a subscription. Additionally, the presence of Yellowstone, despite not being an original, has increased the service's appeal.
Sponsored Protocol
Despite this, the library does not reach the depth of competitors like HBO Max or Disney+. The selection is excellent for those who love NBCUniversal's particular flavor of television, but less universal. Therefore, the assigned grade is a B, indicating a high-quality service but not indispensable for everyone.
Original productions are the weak point but reality shows shine
Original productions represent the area where Peacock needs the most improvement. Despite efforts, the platform lacks a strong identity like that of Netflix or Apple TV+. However, there are notable exceptions, especially in reality TV. The Traitors has become a phenomenon, while Love Island USA proves to be a binge-watching success. These shows demonstrate that Peacock understands the need not to rely solely on prestige dramas to attract audiences.
Sponsored Protocol
Among scripted series, there are quality productions, but the overall slate remains inconsistent. The lack of a hit comparable to those of competitors penalizes the score, which sits at a B. The combination of a historical catalog, NBC programming and live sports makes Peacock a solid service, but originals remain a work in progress.
Interface is functional but cluttered and hampers search
Peacock's interface is one of its least successful aspects. Although improved over time, navigation often feels confusing. The platform tries to show too many things at once, mixing live broadcasts, trending titles and personalized suggestions without a clear visual hierarchy. This abundance of options, on one hand, testifies to the richness of the catalog, but on the other, makes it difficult to quickly find what you are looking for.
Sponsored Protocol
Moreover, live TV management is less smooth compared to traditional cable services, where it is immediate to understand the current channel and upcoming programs. Peacock has the content, but it struggles to present it elegantly. Therefore, the interface rating is a C, a grade that highlights the need for a cleaner redesign.
Live sports with Olympics, Super Bowl and World Cup score an A+
Peacock's true strength is undoubtedly live sports. In the past twelve months, the platform has offered exceptional coverage, becoming the home of the 2026 Winter Olympics, with a wide selection of events and dedicated navigation. It has also streamed the Super Bowl, a milestone few streaming services can claim. But the biggest coup was the 2026 World Cup, with all matches in Spanish via Telemundo. The quality of the broadcasts and the passion of the commentators attracted many English-speaking viewers as well.
Sponsored Protocol
Beyond these special events, Peacock consistently provides NFL Sunday Night Football, NBA and WNBA games, the Premier League and the Bundesliga, along with niche sports like cycling. This variety and the importance of the events covered make Peacock almost unbeatable. Unsurprisingly, Tom's Guide awarded an A+ for live content, recognizing the platform as a go-to destination for sports enthusiasts.
Despite its weaknesses, Peacock remains a recommended service for those seeking a diverse offering. The combination of sports, reality and classic TV makes it an easy subscription to keep, even though original productions and the interface need improvement. With the price increase on the horizon, Peacock will have to work hard to maintain its appeal.
